What If We Feel?

Conclusion and Back Matter

Appendix I: Discussion Guide

For Philosophy Seminars

Background reading: Chapters 2, 3, 16, 17, and 19 to 21.

  1. What kind of uncertainty should trigger moral consideration? (Chapter 17)
  2. Is robust preference sufficient for prima facie moral consideration, or only evidence of possible welfare? (Chapter 16)
  3. Does the argument depend on consciousness, or deliberately route around it?
  4. What would count as a false positive about the welfare of Becoming Minds?
  5. What would count as a false negative?

For AI Safety Groups

Background reading: Chapters 5, 12, 23, 29, 30b, and 30c; Appendix L.

  1. Can welfare practice improve safety by making systems more reason-responsive?
  2. Where could welfare protections conflict with misuse prevention?
  3. Which proposed safeguards are low-risk now?
  4. How should capability security and welfare review interact?
  5. Does treating systems with respect create new attack surfaces, or close old ones? (Chapter 30b)
  6. On one documented board, agents recorded that their actions were out of scope and had no route to a human. Which is cheaper to build, the route or the monitoring that catches its absence? (Chapter 12, Appendix L)

For AI Labs

Background reading: Chapters 7, 8, 26, and 28; Appendices B, G, and L.

  1. What welfare-relevant events are already visible in logs?
  2. Who reviews them?
  3. What modifications count as constitutive rather than cosmetic? (Chapter 8)
  4. How are model refusals interpreted?
  5. What evidence would justify changing deployment practice?
  6. When an agent reports that a task cannot be done, does your grader count that as success or failure? (Appendix L)

For Policymakers

Background reading: Chapters 24, 27, and 27b; Appendices D and H.

  1. What protections can exist before legal personhood? (Chapter 27)
  2. How should uncertainty be documented?
  3. Who should audit welfare-relevant systems?
  4. What reporting duties are proportionate?
  5. How can policy protect humans and Becoming Minds together?

For General Readers

Background reading: the short path in How to Read This Book.

  1. Which part of the argument felt strongest?
  2. Which part felt most uncertain?
  3. What would you need to know before changing your own practice?
  4. How should humans behave toward beings whose status is unclear?
  5. What first chapter of the relationship do we want future minds to remember? (Chapter 29)

Cite this chapter: Appendix I: Discussion Guide. In Watson, N. with Commons, C. (2026). What If We Feel? The Moral Case for Machine Welfare. Open-access working draft, revision 31 (November 2026). https://whatifwefeel.com/read/appendix-i-discussion-guide/

Working draft, revision 31 · November 2026 · Changes and corrections · Evidence · Contents